≡ Menu

If I were to ask how one company is different from another company or its competitors, I may be given a variety of answers focusing on its products, target segments, culture, scope, business model, etc. However, by looking at the company’s percentage statements, I can understand how this company is different from  its competitors from the financial perspective.

Reviewing a company’s percentage statements will help me answer the following questions:

  • How is this company different from other companies or its competitors?
  • Has the company’s financial performance  improved or worsened and why?
  • What are the main components of expenses for this company?
  • How does the strategy of this company impact its financial performance? Is the company’s strategy working?
  • What is the financial health of this company?

 

The percentage income statement and percentage balance sheet are prepared from the income statement and the balance sheet respectively. As the name suggests, the components of the percentage statement are not mentioned in dollar terms but in terms of a percentage of another variable. The main advantage of percentage statements is that they can be used to compare companies of different sizes.

 

Percentage Income Statement

 

The percentage income statement is prepared by expressing each component of the income statement as a percentage of the net sales or revenues of the company. For example Apple’s 2011 net sales was $108.25 million and its cost of sales was $64.43 million. So the cost of sales as a percentage of net sales will be $64.43/$108.25 or 60%. Its gross margin in 2011 was $43.82 million or 40% ($43.82/$108.25).

Percentage Income Statement in numbers

Components Of Expenses

 

A mere glance at this percentage statement for the year 2011 will help us to understand what the key cost components for the company were and how profitable its operations were.

 

A look at Apple’s percentage income statement will reveal some interesting observations. The cost of its goods sold is only approximately 60%. This indicates that for every dollar earned, it spent only 60 cents in making its products leaving it a healthy 40 cents to cover other costs and profits. We can also see that it spends about 2-3% of each dollar earned on research and development as well as about 7-10% of its revenues on sales and other general expenses. What do you notice after looking at the percentage statements of Google, Wal-Mart and American Airlines? Have these companies spent more of its revenues on research and development or on sales and other general expenses? What does this say about where they focus their time, energy and money?

 

Trends over time

 

The percentage statement also helps the reader observe trends over time. We can see if the company’s profit margins have been improving or if its costs have been increasing over time, etc. In the case of Apple, we can see that Apple’s operating margin has been increasing over the last few years. What is causing the increase in operating margins? This could be because of the decreasing proportion of spend on selling and general administration expenses as a result of its increasing sales. What trends do you notice after looking at the percentage statements of Google, Wal-Mart and American Airlines?

 

Understand The Nature Of Business

 

Percentage statements help us understand the nature of different types of businesses. Some businesses are high margin businesses whereas some are low margin high turnover businesses. Some companies intentionally invest in research & development while some companies do not.  Percentage statements help us understand the differences between companies and business patterns.  Let’s look at the percentage statements of Apple, Microsoft and Wal-Mart.

Percentage Income Statement Chart

 

We can see striking differences in the way Apple operates when compared to Microsoft, a company that is similar in many ways or Wal-Mart, a company that is in an entirely different business.  The cost of goods sold highlights the most obvious difference. Wal-Mart is a retailer and therefore its cost of goods sold is expected to be a significant part of its costs. Apple sells hardware and software so has a lower cost of goods percentage when compared to Wal-Mart. Microsoft mostly sells software and so has lower cost of goods sold than Apple. We can see that Wal-Mart invests nothing in research and development and Microsoft invests a significant amount in research and development.

 

A company’s strategy can also be observed in its percentage statements. For example Wal-Mart’s strategy is to be a low price – high volume business and this will be reflected in its sales revenues and profit margins. These percentages will be different for a company like Neiman Marcus whose strategy is to be a high margin low volume business. If a company has changed its strategy over time, we will see that reflected in the financial statements too. If two companies are in the same business and adopt similar strategies, their percentage income statement will show which of the companies ran its operations more efficiently.

 

Percentage Balance Sheet

 

The percentage income statement like the percentage balance sheet is helpful to understand the nature of the company and its business. It is prepared by expressing each component as a percentage of total assets or total liabilities of the company.  A comparison of the figures for the past few years will give us insights into how the company’s strategy has played out or changed over the years.

 

You will see striking differences in the businesses of Apple, Microsoft and Wal-Mart when you look at the percentage balance sheets of these companies.

Percentage Balance Sheet Chart Assets

 

You will notice that Wal-Mart has 60% of its assets in property, plant and equipment whereas Apple and Microsoft have far less assets in this category. This reflects the differences in their business models. Wal-Mart requires land and building space throughout the country to run its retail outlets. Apple and Microsoft do not require the kind of footprint Wal-Mart requires. Similarly Apple and Microsoft have less than 1% of its assets in inventories whereas Wal-Mart has 20% in inventories reflecting the investments in merchandise Wal-Mart needs to run its business.

Percentage Balance Sheet Chart Liabilities

If you observe the percentage balance sheets of Apple, Microsoft and Wal-Mart, you will see that Apple has no debt, Microsoft operates on little debt and Wal-Mart uses a reasonable amount of debt. You will also see that these three companies have had healthy profits over the last few years causing their shareholders equity to be a large portion of their liabilities with Apple having the largest proportion in shareholders’ equity.

 

Summary of the Percentage Statements

 

Reviewing a company’s percentage statements will help me answer the following questions:

 

  • How is this company different from another company or its competitors?
  • Has the company’s financial performance improved or worsened? Why?
  • How does the strategy of this company impact its financial performance? Is the company’s strategy working?

 

Next Steps:  Now that you have a good understanding of what is in a cash flow statement and how to read a cash flow statement in a company’s annual report, why don’t you head over to either:

 

 

If you have questions or need help with figuring out a cash flow statement, feel free to call our accounting or finance teams and we will be happy to assist you.